I'm Apprehensive About a Capital Campaign
If you're thinking about starting a capital campaign, and you have some fears, then you're exactly where you need to be.
When Kaia Sand, the Executive Director of Street Roots at the time, shared the vision for a new building, I felt it. The purpose, the necessity, the belief that the Street Roots community deserved something permanent and dignified. I also felt something else. A quiet panic that I did not say out loud for a while.
Street Roots did not have $1 million in assets when we started. We were tasked with raising $5 million. And over the course of three years, the goal grew, the timeline shifted, and the weight of what we were trying to do became very real.
I remember thinking things like:
What if we go public with this and fall short?
What if we damage the organization's credibility?
What if we ask our best donors and they say no, and we lose the relationship?
What if the board is not ready?
What if I am not ready?
What if we build something and the organization cannot sustain it afterward?
What if we spend years on this and the community never feels the impact we promised?
Those fears are not signs that you are the wrong person for this. They are signs that you understand what is at stake.
What helped was stopping trying to see the whole staircase.
The campaigns that fall apart are usually the ones where the team tried to sprint toward a number before they understood what they were standing on. The campaigns that succeed, including ours, started by doing something much less glamorous. They looked honestly at what they had before asking for anything.
What helped ease those fears was viewing the campaign not as one enormous mountain but as a series of phases, each one designed to answer a specific set of questions before moving to the next.
The first phase is not about raising money. It is about campaign advancement, building the internal foundation, assessing needs, identifying financing options, and beginning to get close to your most loyal supporters. This phase can take years.
For us, a few of those loyal supporters stepped up early to cover the costs of figuring out whether we had a real shot at all. That gift, before a single major ask had been made, made everything that followed possible.
The second phase is a feasibility study. This is where you take your dream and hold it up to reality. You go to the people closest to your organization, donors, board members, community leaders, and you ask them honest questions.
Can this be done?
What do people think of this vision?
How much can realistically be raised and from whom?
What concerns exist that we have not named yet?
For Street Roots, this phase was clarifying in ways we did not expect. It did not shrink the vision. It sharpened it. We screened our donors and found hidden gems we had not fully seen before. We found out we had a board that was ready to show up in any way needed. We learned which relationships were ready, which needed more time, and where the gaps were before we ever made a public ask.
That is the gift of the feasibility study. It transforms a fear-inducing number into a strategy. It turns "we need $5 million" into "here is what we know, here is what we need to build, and here is a sequence that gives us a real shot."
The fear does not fully go away. I will not pretend it does.
But there is a difference between fear that paralyzes and fear that sharpens your attention. The executive directors who lead successful campaigns are not the ones who were never afraid. In fact, the first sign of a powerful and resilient leader is an honest one.
If you are sitting with a vision that feels too big and a balance sheet that feels too small, that is not a reason to wait. That might be exactly the right time to start the first phase and find out what you are working with.
That conversation is one I know well. If you are ready to have it, I am here.